The Mystery of Lyme Disease – Dr Pugliese

The Mystery of Lyme Disease

By Dr. Andrew Pugliese

Four months ago, a 44-year-old woman was referred to me by her audiologist and ENT for acute deafness of the right ear. She is a healthy woman without any past medical history and was not on any medication. Her otolaryngologist (ENT) could not find any physical reason for the patient’s acute unilateral deafness, including a negative CAT scan. She was being referred to me to determine if there was an infection etiology for her deafness.

Infections can cause deafness and it is usually broken down into two broad categories, viruses and Lyme disease. Viruses that have been associated with deafness include measles, mumps and rubella. The patient had been vaccinated for these viruses, as were her children. Also, the patient did not remember having any sort of cold or flu symptoms prior to the illness. This then beg the question – is this Lyme disease?

Woods Can Contain Heavy Tick Populations
Woods Can Contain Heavy Tick Populations

Diagnosing and treating Lyme disease is very controversial in Georgia for several factors, mostly based on the conventional wisdom that there is no Lyme disease in Georgia according to most physicians you talk to in the area. Part of the problem with this belief is that there is too much emphasis on blood tests, and virtually none on history and physical symptoms. Read the CDC website for diagnosing Lyme disease and see how vague it is, not only diagnosing, but treating Lyme disease.

Historically with Lyme disease, only fifty percent of these patients even remember being bitten by a tick. Then somewhere between 50-80% of Lyme patients report the bulls-eye rash that is seen during the acute disseminated phase of the disease, which occurs several weeks after the bite. There are three phases to Lyme disease:
  1. Acute Local – days to weeks
  2. Acute Disseminated – weeks to months
  3. Chronic Disseminated – months to years

Testing for Lyme disease, in my opinion, is not as much unreliable as it is insensitive. In other words, many patients will test negative for Lyme disease but actually do have the disease.

It has been my experience that a positive Lyme test helps, but a negative test does not rule out Lyme disease. There are other diseases that share the same fate. At a recent ABIM board review course, they talked about the insensitivity of ANA testing for lupus. Lupus ANA testing has been found to be very insensitive and the diagnosis is clinical, and not based on laboratory findings. At that same board review they said that the earlier you diagnose and treat Lyme, the better the prognosis. In all the conferences I’ve attended, that is the first time I’ve ever heard that said.

In the case of my patient, both her Lyme Western blot and PCR were negative which meant the diagnosis had to be made clinically. Initially, I tried minocycline orally, but after a few weeks there was no improvement. At this time I decided to try the intravenous route with Rocephin (ceftriaxone), which is always a challenge to get insurance to approve the medication. Fortunately, in this case, insurance had approved the use of Rocephin for more than four weeks. I have to believe that the documentation from her audiologist and ENT helped make the case.

After six weeks of IV therapy, I’m happy to report that the patient now has 40% speech discrimination in the Right ear, which was initially zero. In addition to continuing her IV antibiotics, she is in the process of getting approved for hyperbaric therapy, which has also been shown to work with chronic Lyme patients.

Diagnosing and treating this patient is a labor-intensive effort. It takes patience and understanding in order to be successful. Unfortunately for many in my profession, both are in short supply. Mix that with not fully understanding how to view the data before them, and many patients are dismissed and labeled as kooks. It’s time to be less dismissive and learn to look and listen better.

Meet Andrew Pugliese MD


I am a passionate blogger, author, speaker and Triple Board Certified MD in Internal & Sleep Medicine. I currently an infectious disease physician in Atlanta, GA for Infectious Disease Consultants. I currently serve as President of Sinus Solutions LLC and I’m a  pioneer in the non-surgical treatment of acute and chronic sinusitis. I write informative blog posts that focus on underlying causes, detection and treatment of numerous infectious diseases. These disease range from chronic sinusitis & immune deficiencies to narcolepsy & reflux with a little bit of everything in between.  As a physician, I am in the people fixing business and I hope that somewhere in my blog you find information that will help you become a better you! Comments and questions about any of my posts are always welcome!

My Bio:

Dr. Pugliese recieved his doctorate in medicine from St. George’s University School of Medicine and completed his Infectious Disease Fellowship at Winthrop University Hospital, Mineola, N.Y.  Dr. Pugliese is a member of several professional organizations, including: Infectious Disease Society of GA, Infectious Disease Society of America, American College of Physicians and American Medical Association.

Important Disclaimer: The content displayed by the author of is designed to be educational. Under no circumstance should it replace the expert care and advice of a qualified physician. does not give medical advice or care to its viewers. Rapid advances in medicine may cause information contained here to become outdated, invalid or subject to debate. Accuracy cannot be guaranteed., writers, editors and management assume no responsibility for how information presented is used by the public.